Posted by 
Catholic Views on Surrogacy: What is the Catholic Stance on Reproductive Technology?
The question of whether surrogacy is allowed for Catholics, excluding donated eggs, delves into the complex moral and theological perspectives upheld by the Catholic Church. In short, the Catholic Church does not approve of surrogacy, as it is seen as morally disordered, irrespective of whether donated eggs or sperm are used. This is in line with the broader Catholic views on surrogacy and reproductive technology, which are rooted in the Church’s teachings on the sanctity of marriage, the natural order, and the rights of the child.
What Is Surrogacy, and Why Is It Discouraged in Catholicism?
Surrogacy is generally defined as the practice where an embryo, fertilized using sperm and/or eggs from a couple or third-party donors, is implanted into a woman who is not the biological mother. This woman, the “surrogate,” carries the child to term and, upon birth, hands the child over to the intended parents. In Catholicism, surrogacy is viewed as a moral violation because it disconnects procreation from the natural order of marriage. The Church teaches that children should be conceived through the loving union of a husband and wife, in line with God’s natural design.
In addition, the Church considers surrogacy to be disordered because it involves third parties (such as egg donors or sperm donors) and disrupts the natural parental relationship. The moral views on surrogacy in Catholicism argue that this practice deprives the child of a clear relationship with their biological parents, which is seen as both unnatural and unjust. It’s believed that this disrupts the family structure, which Catholic doctrine holds as sacred and divinely ordained.
Catholic Doctrine on Family and Parenthood
Catholic teaching on parenthood is deeply connected to the belief that procreation should occur within the confines of marriage, a sacred institution designed by God. Surrogacy is seen as a contradiction to natural law, which stresses that every child should be conceived through the loving relationship between a husband and wife. The Catholic Church believes that both the procreative and unitive aspects of marriage must go together — this means that children should be the product of marital love, not reproductive technologies.
In this context, surrogacy presents challenges because it involves a separation of these two purposes of marriage. For example, surrogacy in which a third party carries the child is seen as undermining the dignity of the child, as it does not respect the child’s right to be raised by their biological parents. Additionally, reproductive technologies like IVF and surrogacy are often criticized for objectifying the child and reducing them to a product or commodity rather than a gift from God.
Adoption vs. Surrogacy: A Catholic Perspective
While surrogacy is explicitly condemned, adoption is generally encouraged within the Church. Adoption happens when a child is given up by their birth parents and entrusted to a new family, which, according to Catholic doctrine, is an act of charity and compassion. It is different from surrogacy, as it does not involve pre-conception planning to create a child through artificial means. Adoption, in the Catholic view, is a means of providing care and love to children who need it, but surrogacy starts from a preconceived intention to bring a child into the world through artificial methods, which is why it is viewed negatively.
Catholic Stance on Embryo Adoption and IVF Babies
While the Church strongly opposes surrogacy, there is a somewhat nuanced approach to embryo adoption. Embryo adoption refers to the practice of adopting embryos that have been frozen during IVF procedures. These embryos, often the result of discarded IVF procedures, could be implanted in a woman’s womb to give them a chance at life. The Catholic Church has not definitively accepted or rejected embryo adoption, though it is a difficult moral issue. Some argue that adopting these embryos might be seen as a way to provide life to children who would otherwise be abandoned, while others caution against participating in the artificial reproductive process that created the embryos in the first place.
While this is complex terrain for Catholics, the Church’s focus remains on the moral implications of reproductive technologies and the dignity of the child. Adoption, on the other hand, is generally seen as an acceptable and noble act, as it involves no manipulation of the natural reproductive process.
Conclusion: Catholic Views on Surrogacy and Reproductive Technology
In conclusion, the Catholic views on surrogacy are clear: surrogacy is considered morally disordered and incompatible with Catholic teachings on family, marriage, and parenthood. The Church’s teaching on reproductive technology stresses that children should be conceived through the natural union of husband and wife, not through artificial means. Surrogacy, IVF, and similar practices are seen as disruptive to the sanctity of life, the natural order, and the family unit.
Though adoption is strongly encouraged by the Catholic Church, surrogacy is viewed as an intervention that violates the natural right of the child to be raised by their biological parents. For Catholics, the ethical implications of surrogacy and reproductive technology must be carefully considered, particularly in light of the Church’s longstanding commitment to the dignity and sanctity of life.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):
- What is the Catholic stance on surrogacy?
The Catholic Church opposes surrogacy because it disconnects procreation from the natural union of marriage and devalues the dignity of the child. - Why does the Church oppose reproductive technologies like IVF and surrogacy?
These technologies are seen as morally disordered, as they separate procreation from marital love and treat children as commodities. - Is adoption allowed in Catholicism?
Yes, adoption is encouraged, as it aligns with Catholic values of love, charity, and providing a family to children in need. - What is the difference between surrogacy and adoption in Catholic teachings?
Adoption involves the voluntary giving up of a child for care, while surrogacy involves the planned creation of a child through artificial means, which the Church opposes. - Can Catholics adopt embryos from IVF?
The Church has not definitively ruled on embryo adoption, but it is a complex issue, with some considering it a morally acceptable way to give life to frozen embryos. - Why is surrogacy considered morally disordered in Catholicism?
Surrogacy is considered morally disordered because it involves third-party intervention and undermines the natural bond between parents and children.